Mennonite Church USA Same Sex Marriage Symposium

The following are excerpts from a Mennonite World Review article about the recent Mennonite Church USA symposium on homosexuality in Newton, Kansas.

Page 1 begins:

NEWTON, Kan. — Contrasting views on same-sex marriage in the church highlighted a symposium on homosexuality Oct. 25-26.
Western District Conference of Mennonite Church USA, which has seen eight congregations withdraw after a Kansas pastor officiated at the covenant ceremony of a lesbian couple, sponsored the event.
“The Church and Homo­sex­ual­­ity: A Conversation That Can Hold Us Together” drew 130 people to Faith Mennonite Church.
The main presenters were Keith Graber Miller, a professor of Bible, religion and philosophy at Goshen (Ind.) College, and David Boshart, executive conference minister of MC USA’s Central Plains Conference. Both are ordained pastors.
Boshart advocated welcoming gay and lesbian people in the church while not supporting same-sex marriage as a ministry of the church.
Graber Miller argued that same-sex relationships can be loving, pure, just and fruitful and that the church should bless and honor them…

-page 1, MC USA district airs contrasting viewpoints during homosexuality symposium

Page 3 continues:

Loving relationships

Graber Miller said there is no evidence that the biblical writers knew of genuine same-sex orientation. He said they condemned abusive acts but did not address loving relationships.
“Seven passages, including about 50 verses in the Old and New Testaments combined, deal with this issue, and in every case the context suggests idolatry, violent rape, lust, unnatural behaviors or exploitation,” he said.
“I believe the biblical passages dealing with same-sex sexuality are addressing something other than the loving, community-affirmed, covenant same-sex relationships we know today.”
The church has long acknowledged the reality of same-sex orientation, he said.
“Would it not be good to channel those orientations into loving, God-blessed commitments marked by monogamy and fidelity, supported and held accountable by bodies of believers?” he asked. “That would allow for sustainable, life-giving commitments in a way that hiddenness, denial and denunciation do not.”
Graber Miller called for MC USA and its conferences to allow congregations to dissent from the denomination’s stance on homosexual practice — an issue that he said is not at the core of Christian faith nor central to the Anabaptist tradition.
“I’m asking that conferences allow those congregations and their leaders who painstakingly and faithfully come to views divergent from what is considered the norm — divergences rooted in communal congregational discernment of Scripture with the guidance of the Holy Spirit — to be allowed to coexist alongside those with other views,” he said.

-page 3, MC USA district airs contrasting viewpoints during homosexuality symposium



Canadian MB conference begins a discussion of sexuality
Canadian Conference of MB Churches

The Conversation Has Begun


5 thoughts on “Mennonite Church USA Same Sex Marriage Symposium

  1. Ugh. The Mennonites are on the way to becoming “mainstream” in all the worst ways.

    My sister went to Goshen and back in the early 90’s they already had an LGBT support group…no wonder the professor of “Bible” at Goshen doesn’t even believe in inspiration and thinks that the writers of scripture were idiots.

    The Canadian conference isn’t far behind, unless the conservative majority grows spines and starts flexing their denominational muscle.

    The blind three legged dog of liberalism needs to be taken behind the barn and put out of it’s misery.

  2. Pingback: Mennonite University Considering Policy Change to Allow Homosexual Faculty | Menno-lite

  3. Pingback: Will Mennonites Make Space to Welcome Sin? | Menno-lite

  4. Pingback: Where will the Same-Sex Conversation Lead? | Menno-lite

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s